I was DECEIVED BY ECKHART TOLLE (True Story)
November 17, 2011 in Anna's Process Blog
A couple of years ago, I had the opportunity to join Eckhart Tolle, as he came to speak in Denmark. My friend and I saw that he was coming several months prior to that and decided to go and see him and hopefully talk to him. In spite of both of us being quite poor, my friend was a single mother with a small child and I was a student, we saved up the equivalent of 250 Euro or 370 US $ that the ticket to see Tolle costed. Both of us had prior to this read “The Power of Now” and at that stage I had started reading “A New Earth” as well. So you can say that we were hardcore Tolle fans, although my friend was (and as far as I know still is) a bigger fan than me. I was fascinated by the story of how Eckhart Tolle became Eckhart Tolle, meaning how he got from being a German College nobody to being a spiritual guide for millions of people (not to mention a very rich man). At the time I was very interested in disengaging the personality as I perceived to be in the way of “the real me”. Tolle both supported that view, but also nuanced it by saying that we should accept ourselves unconditionally. That sounded good to me. However what I have only realized recently, was that I was even more fascinated by how Tolle had achieved the status he had. I secretly desired becoming a guru, a superhero, a star and of course having a lot of money, in such a way where no one would blame me for it and where I would go to sleep with a good conscience. If there are any readers out there who are familiar with Tolle’s work and life (perhaps more than me), you will know that he was a university professor teaching in Germany at the time where he had his “enlightening” break-through. He was miserable with his life, at the brink of suicide and suddenly he experienced himself breaking into two parts. After that he was more or less enlightened and the story goes that he spent the next two years or so in a state of permanent bliss, sitting on a park bench. He sat there until a publisher, who had felt drawn to him, came and gave him a lot of money and an opportunity to write a book. (At least that is how I remember reading the story) I went to Tolle’s website to double check this story and here the description is even more vauge:
“At the age of 29, a profound inner transformation radically changed the course of his life. The next few years were devoted to understanding, integrating and deepening that transformation, which marked the beginning of an intense inward journey.”
So he had this amazing experience, which I was extremely fascinated of. In my eyes he had so easily broken free of the chains of personality, experience and even the runt of an everyday life. So he became my roll model in that sense, rather than his teachings actually “speaking” to me. Believe me, I tried. I tried feeling it, being it and I did practice the exercises that Tolle suggested. But looking back at my experiences with Tolle, it was as much an inner as an outer scam. Back to the day where I ‘met’ Eckhart Tolle. My friend and I arrived at the place where Tolle would speak, which was a huge concert hall in the center of Copenhagen. Thousands of people were there, mostly women, and some men and slowly the room filled up. I applied within myself a reverent expression, and I saw others doing the same. At the same time I was struggling inside myself with “feeling it”. I had previously gone to spiritual conventions and often felt cheated in that most of it were clearly created for profit, yet pretending to be “enlightened” and benevolent. It made me sick, but I kept going. I had a similar experiences with the Tolle event, especially cause I had spent so much money on seeing him. So I mustered a serene an calm feeling and sat down waiting for “the man himself to arrive”. I could see below me further down on the front seats a row of celebrities that I knew from TV and the tabloids. They also looked very serene, yet in an elitist “front-row” kind of way. If I recall correctly, one of them was wearing sunglasses. Then he came out, Tolle and he talked and it was difficult to hear what he was saying. I tried getting some of his energy, by sort of awkwardly ”opening myself up” to him, but it did not really work. I could not feel it and afterwards I blamed myself and believed that there was something wrong with me because I was not able to “feel it” and get a profound spiritual experience from listening to Tolle (and after having paid that much money). Soon after that, I stopped reading Tolle’s books and I slowly but surely started realizing how I had in fact deceived myself into a major self-delusion through the “support” of Eckhart Tolle’s books and the entire movement that he represented. I realized that what I required was to be self-honest with and as myself. That is another story. Now – if one goes to Tolle’s website, the very first point that springs in ones eyes, is the sentence “Creating a new world together”. When I was a Tolle-Follower, I believed that we were in fact changing the world, through following Tolle, through meditating and “accepting myself unconditionally” and essentially applying the Buddhist principle of avoiding desires and separating oneself from the mental experience of self. However, if we have a self-honest look at the world – which is simply to look at what is here, physically and in fact – it is clear that the world is not going to change from us drawing ourselves back into ourselves and refrain from standing self-responsible for this world through separating ourselves from what is Here. I realized this within and as myself, when I started simply applying self-honesty and for the first time in years were able to move myself and accelerate my process. Until then I had followed teachings such as Tolle’s that actually supports people to separating themselves from who and as how they’ve allowed themselves to exist and within that supporting them to abdicate self-responsibility. At the same time there is an entire hype that “we ARE changing the world” and “we ARE raising consciousness” – and it was within that I started blaming myself because I was not “feeling it”. No wonder I was not feeling it – it is not real. Changing reality starts with actually changing the reality of and as ourselves within standing self-responsible for all and everything we exist within and as – to do this we require to bring all of ourselves together, not to separate ourselves into parts – which is ironic as Tolle and the entire movement promotes ‘oneness’ – but the problem is that this oneness is disregarding equality and thereby ends up being oneness of and as deception – a coming together in a mutal deceptive oneness. This can clearly be seen within my ‘encounter’ with Eckhart Tolle – how more than 2000 people were gathered, all paying a large sum of money simply to hear Tolle speak. It can also be seen within how it was pop culture celebrities for whom the front rows were reserved for. It can also be seen within my experience of pretentious serenity and reverence that I most likely shared with every other person in that room. Where is “the world” that we are apparently changing in any of this? Where is it really in Tolle’s words? When do any of the Tolle followers actually stand up for Life in self-honesty? Several videos on Youtube from different (Destonian) users criticizing Tolle has been removed from Youtube on a claim of Copyright infringement from the “Tolle Movement” – since Youtube complied and since there is an industry of spirituality behind Tolle, we can (at least polemically) conclude that this means that one is not allowed to question ’the establishment’ of capitalist-lightworkers because within doing so, one might risk to expose the scam that spirituality is and has become. I was deceived by Eckhart Tolle – but I was really deceived by myself. I allowed myself to deceive myself because I preferred having closed eyes. I preferred a program where I could conveniently within a belief that I was changing the world, sustained by an millions of people around the world doing the same (albeit only the middleclass Elite) yet continue to exist in and as abdication of self-responsibility. Eckhart Tolle as such ironically represents the system of inequality, deception and separation. Therefore, when you got a capitalist-lightworker like Echart Tolle against you, you know you’re in the ‘right spot’ and should simply keep on doing what you are doing. I AM ONE VOTE FOR A DIRECT WORLD – WITH NO SPIRITUAL MIDDLE-MEN I AM ONE VOTE FOR AN EQUAL MONEY SYSTEM – TO ENSURE THAT THE ONENESS WE LIVE, IS EQUAL AND DIGNIFIED FOR ALL LIFE. I AM ONE VOTE FOR A HUMAN BEING THAT VALUES LIFE AS LIFE












Cool writings! Thanks for pointing out – that’s why I couldn’t read his books, getting into this ‘hazy’ world of CONsciousness from it – ew. We stop going there
Cool, thanks for sharing Anna!
My opinion is that Sounds True, Tolle’s media company, has contributed greatly to the distortion of his purpose. I, too, attended a live event and had very similar feelings. It completely changed my sense of who he is. The Sounds True founder introduced him–all the time being ultra serious, “reverend” and kind of phony, and the actual event just seemed completely wrong to me. I also could not hear or understand his words. I stood up and walked out, facing thousands and thousands of eyes looking at me leave as I walked down the isle to the back doors. It didn’t bother me. What I learned from Tolle I learned early on, when he was merely a simple teacher–before he was transformed to a media sensation.
Einstein never refuted Newtonian Lows of physics he expanded it and while studying quantum mechanics you never reject Einstein theory of relativity but use it as a stepping stone to go beyond its realms towards new discoveries. That should be the case while listening to Eckhart tolle words. Every person has his own way of experiencing the event of life. Collect from around the world what can take you further in your journey of self discovery. In certain aspects your criticism is justified and need answers form Eckhart tolle but at the same time we must realize that many philosophers are trying to explain through some logic the cosmic drama and non can claim to have the absolute wisdom and all the answers.
You were not deceived by Tolle, it seems to me you missed the essence of what he's saying.
Now, I myself was never too involved with Tolle. I never bought his books and CDs not attended his seminars. I only read a few materials and saw some videos with him after a friend mentioned his name.
His studies are essentially that of Zen Buddhism, with some additional details which he's come up with on his own, or other influences.
Your problem is that you wanted magic. Receiving "his energy" what the hell is that stuff? Did he ever claim to send a doze of magical energy to people who attend? I see no such thing.
You wanted an easy solution. Give money, get a fix. You wanted to be rich and famous. To be a guru. Your words. Those very desires are the exact opposite of what Tolle tells his followers to do. You didn't accept yourself, you didn't abandon desires, you didn't live in the current moment. You were daydreaming. None of this is Tolle's message.
Is Tolle commercial? Sure. If he wasn't, you wouldn't know about him. He simply adapted his message for the kind of world we live in, which includes commerce and money changing hands. This is how you get people organized for a bigger purpose in a capitalist society. All the people involved in creating and distributing his products have to be paid. But that doesn't mean he deceives people.
I'm afraid the one who deceived you… is you.
I think this is a very interesting topic. Very hard to talk about it or explain it for me personally. I try to understand your thoughts Anna, I never experienced Tolle’s work like you did and Ill never will because I don’t see him as somebody with ALL the answers. The way he became how he is now doesn’t interest me. I would never go and see him, his books give me enough wisdom to help me on my path to be a happier person. 8 years ago I read The Power Of Now for the first time and for me I was reading a lot of things I kinda knew or believed already but to see it written on paper opened a new world for me. I stopped reading all the time, looked in front of me, thought about what I just read and shouted out, this is it, thats what it is, thats whats important. If you had that too when you read his books why could he possibly deceived you, he just tries to brings his believes out in the world. I think you can only learn from it living better with yourself and with others. Wanting to ‘feel’ something from seeing him talk is just weird and won’t happen. For me is listening to him not an option anyway because the matter is way to complicated I think. I have to see it written down to understand it fully.
Hi.
There’s nothing in my blog that is personally about Tolle. So the title is more of a teaser than me actually feeling deceived by Tolle at a personal level. However – I will say that all these spiritual gurus are deceptive and we as people are sinking it willingly in because we want to belive what they’re saying is true. It is simply not so.
Investigate Desteni: http://www.youtube.com/sunettespies
ALL religions are distorted, filled with flaws and nonsense, as well as having some basic truths. Zen Buddhism isn’t any different. I went to a Tolle lecture here in Santa Cruz, CA as friends spoke highly of him. It was only $10 or $20; I would not pay more than that. I fell asleep during the lecture, could not keep my eyes awake even though I tried. I did not even resonate with his books, the details that he wrote and spoke about. I also did not like the selling of photos of him in the back of the room. What was THAT about? That turned me off even further. Connecting with one’s higher self and INTEGRATING that into your life by following through with your inner guidance and living your life according to your inner being (rather than separating) is the key to enlightenment and to “feeling it.” Please check out my blog, I have many articles on this topic.
Christine Hoeflich recently posted..Many Lost Faith After December 21 2012 Non-Event
I have never attended any of his lectures and I won’t because what matters to me is his message not his body and energy ect…..He is a spirit like me so I don’t see the point to go and see his form or listen to his voice.. As far as I know the money he collects is spent on miserable people in the world , so be happy the money you paid fed many suffering people:) he declared it in one of his You Tube lectures.
For the photograph thing..I don’t think Eckhart knows that the ego is taking advantage of his message on front of the theater.
Having been around a while and experienced a lot of things both inner and outer, it is quite clear to me what happened here – and it is something we all go through if we are honest with ourselves. The problem is not ET’s teaching, but the way your mind took hold of them and developed an agenda for a certain kind of power and control. This is what all minds do, so it is nothing to be ashamed of – simply to become aware of. And ET’s teachings and “presence” are not at all compatible with the kinds of projections your mind put forward. But many spiritual teachers will respond to such projections, and help reinforce the mind’s delusions. I could name many, many new age and spiritual teachers who are simply peddling large amounts of delusion, or worse still, dark energy. ET is not one of them. ET’s teachings are incredibly simple because awakening is very, very simple. Far too simple for most people, who want bells and whistles and choruses of angels. Or perhaps even the delusion that they can “manifest” whatever their ego wants simply by believing it enough.
So you should thank Tolle that he did not respond to the audience’s projections. The good thing is that you are already honest enough to be aware of an ego agenda – to seek money, fame and attention through becoming a guru. In fact a big part of becoming more aware is simply gently acknowledging such ego agendas without judgment or condemnation. That’s how the ego become a friend on your journey, and not a sneaky side-kick. I consider myself to be very intuitive, and having befriended my own ego I can quickly see when a spiritual teacher is engaging in deception or self-deception. All I can say is that I have never had any sense from any book or video I have seen of ET that he is anything less than 100% genuine. Perhaps in the future you might return to his teachings and see them in a different light.
Marcus T Anthony recently posted..Elisabet Sahtouris video – “Celebrating Crisis”